| Issue | #1 |
| Published | 1997 |
| Cover Price | 3.95 USD; 5.50 CAD |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Darren Vincenzo |
| Characters | Superman; Flash; Batman; Green Lantern; Catwoman |
| Genre | superhero |
| Pencils | Rodolfo Damaggio |
| Inks | Robert Campanella |
| Characters | Superman; Lois Lane |
| Synopsis | Lois Lane tells about one of Superman's first Christmases in Metropolis. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | David Michelinie [as Barry Jameson] |
| Pencils | Graham Nolan |
| Inks | Josef Rubinstein |
| Colors | Jason Wright |
| Letters | Albert DeBuzman |
| Notes | Writer credit from Rob Allen, via GCD Errors List. |
| Characters | Highfather; Orion |
| Synopsis | Highfather and Orion serve as Santa and an elf on Christmas Eve. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Walter Simonson |
| Pencils | Sal Buscema |
| Inks | Sal Buscema |
| Colors | Lee Loughridge |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | Catwoman |
| Synopsis | Catwoman saves a mother and child on Christmas Eve. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Dennis ONeil |
| Pencils | Jesse Delperdang |
| Inks | Mike Sellers |
| Colors | Lee Loughridge |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | The Demon |
| Synopsis | The Demon brings a Christmas present to a child at the expense of her father's soul. |
| Genre | superhero; occult |
| Script | Ty Templeton |
| Pencils | Ty Templeton |
| Inks | Ty Templeton |
| Letters | Ty Templeton |
| Characters | Green Lantern |
| Synopsis | Green Lantern rescues a Hanukkah vessel with the help of a miracle. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Michael Jan Friedman |
| Pencils | Roger Robinson |
| Inks | Phyllis Novin |
| Colors | John Kalisz |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | Flash [Wally West]; Linda Park |
| Synopsis | Wally gets Linda the perfect gift. |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Mark Waid; Brian Augustyn |
| Pencils | Paul Ryan |
| Inks | Dick Giordano |
| Colors | Tom McCraw |
| Letters | John Costanza |
| Characters | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Alfred Pennyworth |
| Synopsis | Is Christmas Eve any different for Batman and Alfred? |
| Genre | superhero |
| Script | Jim Aparo |
| Pencils | Jim Aparo |
| Inks | Kevin Nowlan |
| Colors | Kevin Nowlan |
| Letters | John Costanza |