| Issue | #4 |
| Published | July 1966 |
| Frequency | Bi-Monthly |
| Cover Price | 0.35 USD |
| Pages | 68 |
| Editing | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Gray Morrow (painting) |
| Inks | Gray Morrow (painting) |
| Colors | Gray Morrow (painting) |
| Letters | typeset |
| Script | Archie Goodwin ? |
| Pencils | Roy G. Krenkel |
| Inks | Roy G. Krenkel |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | in Eerie (Warren, 1966 series) #12 (November 1967); in Eerie (Warren, 1966 series) #18 (November 1968) |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Jerry Grandenetti (ghosting for Joe Orlando) |
| Inks | Joe Orlando |
| Reprinted | in Eerie (Warren, 1966 series) #25 (January 1970) |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie (host); Harvey Whittaker; Phyllis Whittaker (Death) |
| Synopsis | Harvey Whittaker thinks he can take advantage of the story of a crazed hatchet murderer so that he can kill his wife without suspicion, but there's one little fact that he overlooked. |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Gene Colan (signed) |
| Inks | Gene Colan (signed) |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | in Eerie Annual (Warren, 1971 series) #1971 (1971) |
| Script | Ron Parker |
| Pencils | Rocco Mastroserio |
| Inks | Rocco Mastroserio |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Synopsis | A new young doctor arrives to work at an asylum under a respected psychiatrist. His first sight is a tormented man screaming and battering the padded walls of his cell, seemingly incurable. |
| Genre | horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Steve Ditko |
| Inks | Steve Ditko |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Reprinted | in Eerie Yearbook (Warren, 1969 series) #1970; in Eerie (Gold Star Publications, 1972 series) #4 (1973) |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Norman Nodel [as Donald Norman] |
| Inks | Norman Nodel [as Donald Norman] |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Characters | Cousin Eerie (host); Sturgis; Cthylla; Shoggath |
| Synopsis | When a whaling ship finds a man named Sturgis floating on the sea he tells them an incredible story of an island where Shoggath lives and the tragedy that happened there. Unfortunately, the story of Shoggath did not end when he escaped from the island. |
| Genre | Horror |
| Script | Archie Goodwin |
| Pencils | Gray Morrow |
| Inks | Gray Morrow |
| Letters | Ben Oda |
| Notes | Cover featured story. |
| Reprinted | in Eerie Annual (Warren, 1971 series) #1971 (1971); in Eerie Greatest Hits (Harris Comics, 1994 series) #[nn]; in Eerie (Gold Star Publications, 1972 series) #3 (1972) |