| Issue | #17 |
| Published | April-May 1966 |
| Cover Price | 0.12 |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Richard Hughes |
| Notes | Indian medicine man doing rain dance to drench Herbie in pilgrim's outfit // Kurt Schaffenberger (assumed) |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Pencils | Kurt Schaffenberger |
| Inks | Kurt Schaffenberger |
| Notes | Indian medicine man doing rain dance to drench Herbie in pilgrim's outfit // Kurt Schaffenberger (assumed) |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker; Pincus Popnecker; Mrs. Popnecker; Myles Standish; John Alden; Priscilla Mullins |
| Synopsis | Herbie's family owes money dating back to the Mayflower. Herbie travels back in time to set things straight. |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Script | Richard Hughes (as Shane O'Shea) |
| Pencils | Ogden Whitney |
| Inks | Ogden Whitney |
| Letters | Ed Hamilton |
| Reprinted | in Herbie #2 (A-plus February 1990) |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker; Mrs.Popnecker; Pincus Popnecker |
| Synopsis | Herbie is the new kid in school. He proves his bravery by going to a haunted house. Supernatural beings (a witch, a ghost, a creep, and Frankenstein) cause havoc, but prove to be no match for Herbie, his lollipops, or his magic. |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Script | Richard Hughes (as Shane O'Shea) |
| Pencils | Ogden Whitney |
| Inks | Ogden Whitney |
| Letters | Ed Hamilton |
| Notes | Herbie looks and talks differently in this pre-Herbie series story. |
| Reprinted | from Forbidden Worlds #94 (March-April 1961), with commentary |