| Issue | #58 |
| Published | October 1959 |
| Frequency | Monthly, except for March, June, September, and December |
| Cover Price | 0.10 USD |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Phyllis Reed |
| Genre | Romance |
| Pencils | John Romita? |
| Notes | Synopses and some other information from Ed Boner, July 2009. |
| Notes | art is the same border from previous issues |
| Synopsis | The librarian believes that love is sweet, warm, and wonderful; the writer believes that it's hard, cruel, and full of despair. Like they say, opposites attract. |
| Genre | Romance |
| Pencils | Bill Draut |
| Inks | Bill Draut |
| Synopsis | Hank just happened to be the first guy Cathy met in her new town. Nothing special, but they found the most interesting places...romantic places. If only she were with the right guy. It's when she meets the "right guy" that she finds the "magic" wasn't in the places, but with the "right guy." |
| Genre | Romance |
| Synopsis | A writer rents a beach house, partly for privacy, partly to get away from the girl he's broken up with. Enter Wilma, who becomes his friend and ends up hearing the details of his breakup. Falling for the writer, Wilma starts to understand the other woman's perspective, and explains it to him. But is she pushing him back into the other woman's arms? |
| Genre | Romance |
| Genre | Romance |
| Script | Ann Martin |
| Letters | Typeset |
| Notes | Advice Column |
| Synopsis | Mib has had a crush on Jimmy since grade school, but he never pays her attention. Until a friend points out to her that some boys don't like to be chased. It isn't until she stops chasing, that she gets caught. |
| Genre | Romance |
| Notes | On inside back cover. |
| Notes | On back cover. |