Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Just sent some additional comics from my over 50 year old collection for your consideration. Have always had a good experience with your company.
— David W., Mechanicsburg, PA

Submitting comics to sell was a very easy and pleasant experience. Thank you!
— Charlotte E., Salem, MA

Just wanted to reiterate how much I love you guys. The selling process was amazingly simple. Thanks again!
— Ryan G., Kirksville, IL

Thank you for the courteous and prompt service! My Comic Shop has been great to do business with—pleasant, knowledgeable, and definitely wonderful customer service.
— Kristine M., Grosse Pointe, MN

You've been great to work with during the process of buying my comics, and have reflected a high quality business with integrity.
— Mark E., Charleston, SC

In my experience, I found the Mycomicshop site to be very ethical, helpful, and prompt in their service. I happened upon the site when I was looking to sell my father's pulp comic books from 1939 through 1953 and it was the best thing I did.
— Lnda B., Milwaukee, WI

First time selling! Love your company. Have been buying from you for years.
— Ryan G., Kirksville, IL

Thanks for everything you do.
— Fred M., Holland, OH

I appreciate the chance to do business with Mycomicshop again. Started purging my boxes of comics and came across a few goodies I'm ready to sell.
— Matt F., National City, CA

I am looking to sell my comic book collection. I took great care of them, they are all in plastic sleeves and have been since the 80's. Your site is really easy to navigate and use. I look forward to hearing from you!
— Meghan F., Livingston, MT

After shopping my Hulk #181 around I am now ready to sell. Your offer beat the others. I like your company and feel that your offers are fair.
— Frank C., Anaheim, CA

Your staff was a great help in answering my initial questions. Great website listing design and easy to use. Have many more comic boxes to go through and look forward to working with you.
— Robert C., Chesapeake, VA

Hi! My name is Hayley and I've been collecting comics for a few years. I really don't have anything older, but I still have some good stuff! Considering my local store told me he wouldn't even look at any of my boxes, I'm literally blown away by your website/business and I've enjoyed going through my entire collection, paring down, and researching. Honestly, you guys are helping me out if you end up taking these books. (I've got some bills to pay). THANK YOU SO MUCH! I look forward to hearing from you.
— Hayley B., Hamilton Ontario, Canada

Thank you for making the consignment process easy and comfortable. Trey, you were awesome!
— Victoria T., Fernley, NV

This is my second time now doing a trade with you. I'll be using the credit to collect more vintage Wonder Woman comics. :) Thanks!
— James C., Ferndale, WA

Hi Buddy, I’m so glad my sister was home when you called. She also very much enjoyed talking with you. We were extremely pleased with the offer you made for the boxes of paperbacks which we submitted to you. The pricing exceeded all expectations given that we've had some less than satisfactory dealings with our local used book shops. We would highly recommend your services. We thought we’d make a little more than the break-even amount since the shipping was expensive, but we were amazed at how much more we were offered than we had anticipated. We cannot recommend you highly enough to anyone considering selling their paperback collections.
— Marina P., Willowbrook, IL

Thanks again for providing awesome customer service! You guys really are the best and I've told all of my friends about how great you are. Apologies that I keep missing your phone calls. Our workload sounds similar!
— James L., Colombus, OH

You guys make selling my comics easy!
— Jeff R., Englewood, OH

Great day at a one day comic show. Struck some Golden Age, now offered her to you via W-trans.
— Carl S., Fort Wayne, IN

This is my first time selling comics with mycomicshop.com. You were recommended to me by a friend and happy customer of yours!
— Bartek P., Portland, OR

It's great to be able to find and price old and new comics.
— Vernon S., Susquehanna, PA

Great auction in the auctions again this week. You guys keep it rolling and keep me spending. More for my auctions: I’m sending with the Black Panther book the following items: Spectacular Spider-Man 28 CGC 9.8, Spider-Man (1990) Silver Poly-bagged CGC 9.2, Tarzan (1977)19 CGC 6.5 and Ultimate Spider-Man (2000)7 CGC 9.4. Great auctions! You and your staff amaze me.
— Marc T., Walton Beach, FL

I enjoyed doing business with you and your staff. Everyone was polite, responsive, and professional (Jon in particular). Everything was straightforward and trustworthy. I have some additional items I will be bringing your way in the near future.
— George L., Ames, IA

I just have to say, once again, how much I LOVE your trade option. It keeps me on the lookout for 'treasures' to buy and trade to you to fill holes in my collection.
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

You guys are phenomenal! All of this is very new to me (selling my comics) and you have made it so easy to do everything. Thank you so much!
— Lindsey L., Bushnell, FL

Buddy! It's been a pleasure sending you bundle after bundle of comic books for offers. Your website is extremely easy to work with. The process of selecting comics to sell is quick and actually kinda fun! Thanks for the phone chat last week regarding my 16 long boxes. I'm looking forward to sending them your way as well!
— Fernando O., New York, NY

I have been collecting comics since the mid-80's and have amassed a pretty good collection. The short boxes have overtaken my basement and it was time to "thin the herd." I took some of my long boxes over to my local store, but all they offered was $20 a box. I tried different other selling options including web sites hoping to sell my comics at a reasonable price. No luck until I stumbled across you folks. My wishes came true. Thus far I have loaded a quarter of my comic collection into your database and I am happy with the prices I have been offered. It is a little bit of a learning curve on grading, but I'm getting there. I just sent my second box and there will be more on the way. Thanks for awesome service and fair pricing!
— Matt J., Haverhill, MA

I'm not a dealer, just a reader who wants her garage back, so I suspect my grading is off. I hope your buyers enjoy these as much as I did.
— Eva V., Alameda, CA

I found a few more comics to sell to you. I was very pleased with our previous transactions. Thanks.
— George H., Sevierville, TN

I liked the ordering process and, of course, I liked that I could use my trade credit to pay for the entire thing including the shipping and tax. I am looking forward to getting these comics and to doing more trading! Thanks.
— Rex E., McKinney, TX

You guys are fantastic! Thank you so much for all you do!
— Lindsey L., Bushnell, FL

Thanks for offering such a great service in looking up comic book pricing and being able to list them.
— Matthew W., Doylestown, PA

Thanks so much for having the trade for credit option. I absolutely love it! It's helped me to downsize a lot of miscellaneous stuff I've collected over the years and fill in various spots in my collection. I also always keep my eyes open for items when I'm out and about.
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

Thanks Buddy! You guys are great! I just sent off one last short box. With that I will have sold everything to you. Thanks for being so awesome and easy to work with!
— James L., Columbus, OH

Love your trade option!
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

I appreciate your honesty and I am pleased with the way the sale went regarding your purchase of my comics and Edgar Rice Burroughs book collection.
— Linda W., Duncan, OK

I just discovered your website and am very impressed with your company and prices! So excited to be doing business with you, and hoping you can find some great new homes for my books!
— Tessa S., Anahein, CA

You guys and girls are the best!
— Sarah H., Southington, CT

Mr. Saunders, Just received your check. Was happy about the amount paid for my comics. Once I finish a project I'm doing, I'll put together more boxes.
— Greg K., Saint Louis, MO

I wanted to let you know that I just got the check in the mail. It was a pleasure working with you. You made selling my comic so easy. I really felt like the process was fair to both you and me. I still have 30 CGC graded books and I will be in touch when I am ready to sell those. Thanks for your promptness.
— Mark G., Des Moines, Iowa

Buddy, I received your check and want to thank you again for the purchase and for reimbursing part of the shipping costs.
— Holly K., Murfreesboro, TN

Thanks for your excellent continued service and fair pricing for the comics I have sent in.
— Adam N., Manassas, VA

I love your service!
— Daryl T., Lake Worth, FL

Thank you, Buddy, for making what I considered an extremely fair offer for my Golden Age comics. I was very pleasantly surprised, as you could no doubt tell by my reaction.
— Gary M., King, NC

Hi Buddy, Everything looks good. The total of $644 matches with my numbers based on your earlier per book offer. Thank you for another smooth transaction. It’s truly a pleasure working with you and your fantastic team!
— Zachary A., Dallas, TX

Hi Buddy, Thank you for your time in putting together an offer for my comics, an offer which I accept.
— Art H., Aspen, CO

Your buying partner, Phil, came over last week and went through my collection to see what it was worth. It was pretty much bronze and copper editions, but he checked the boxes pretty thoroughly. Honestly, I was sorry to see everything go, but I'm super happy with your offer. Phil was really nice and a pleasure to do business with. I'm so glad your company exists. You helped remove the stress of wondering what the heck I was going to do with this mess of comics. Tell Phil I said hi and thank you both so much for the quick response.
— Liz K., Los Angeles, CA

I received the payment for my comics. I appreciate the business we are doing. Best wishes and a productive rest of 2017 to you.
— Long N., Everett, WA

I recently sold my childhood comic book collection to Buddy Saunders at My Comic Shop. I dealt directly with Buddy. He patiently explained my options for selling the collection. After providing a listing of the collection, Buddy immediately made an offer. He then requested sample scans of some of the older titles. After receiving the scans, Buddy increased his offer. I shipped my comics on a Monday and by the next Monday I received a check for the agreed upon amount. Throughout the entire process, Buddy was professional and fair. Five stars for My Comic Shop and Buddy Saunders!
— Thomas R., Belleville, IL

Selling to you has been a great experience. You are running a fantastic and professional service. I was glad to send my Dad's 1950's EC collection to you with no worries.
— Lance S., Newman, CA