Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I sold several thousand comics to you a few years ago. I was treated very fairly and that is why I am back. It is time now to sell my better books to you.
— Rich B., Detroit Lakes, MN

Thank you for your prompt evaluation and payment for our comic book collection. We packaged up our collection and mailed it to your company with our contact information. You called us to explain the offer and handled the whole transaction in a very professional matter. We recommend your company to anyone who is interested in selling a comic book collection.
— Rob and Jean D., Virginia Beach, VA

It's a wonderful service that you guys provide here!
— Mark M., Tempe, AZ

I have made deals with you in the past and I have been happy with your grading, so let's keep it going. Here's another batch of comics.
— Raul R., Tempe, AZ

I've done business with you before, in the long ago past. You are more than fair and great to work with. Expect many more transactions from me.
— Matthew F., Hertford, NC

Your auctions continue to be the highlight of my collecting. Along with the Amazing Spider-Man 74 and Harvey 4, I would like to send Incredible Hulk 194 CGC 7.0 and ASM 359 CGC 9.2. Keep the comics rolling on your auctions. We all still have a lot of holes to fill in our collections.
— Marc T., Fort Walton Beach, FL

These comics will fill another box that's coming to you for buy/trade! By the way, the 7 comics I won in your May auction are slated to arrive tomorrow. I'm really looking forward to them!
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

I love your site!
— Samuel S., Tuscon, AZ

I don't know if you remember, but back in March I had a conversation with you on the phone. I advised I was sending in a bunch of my comics so I could get an Amazing Fantasy 15 at my local comic shop, but it was on the condition that I pay it off in three months. So over the next two months, I sold some of my other comics in your auctions. I ended up with the cash I needed plus some. So thanks to you, I will be the proud owner of an Amazing Fantasy 15 CGC 4.5 in about two weeks!
— Keith O., Pittsburgh, PA

This sales batch starts a new box! By the way, when I got up this AM, I saw that you had posted various lower grade post-WWII comics last night. Some scarce funny animal, etc. So, I ordered about half a dozen! Looking forward to getting them.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

I'm clearing out closet space, and from past experience, I know that dealing with MCS will be smooth and painless.
— Mike A., Alexandria, VA

I heard so many positive things about your site. That is the reason I want to join in the party and do business with your company. Beyond those I'm listing in my first offer to you, I have thousands more comics. I hope we can be successful doing business together.
— Lam T., Seattle, WA

Buddy, my youngest daughter comes home from the university on Sunday. One of her summer jobs will be to help me reorganize some 25,000 comics that I have picked up to sell or trade to you. I am going to do a deep reorganization including using your bar code scan option for item entry. I want to be able to send you 2,000 books a month.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

I am looking forward to continuing business with mycomicshop. I have purchased quite a few comics from you and you are my absolute favorite. I am looking forward to using my trade money toward the latest Guardians of the Galaxy run.
— Zac C., Brunswick, OH

I've been selling my comic collection through My Comic Shop for the past couple years now, and I wanted to thank you for making the process so easy. You've implemented a great system that takes so much of the guesswork (and just plain work) out of selling comics. Thank for your help.
— Ali L., Puyallup, WA

This is my second shipment of romance comics for sale to you. I was pleased with the outcome of the first sale. Your website and method of buying items from sellers is superb.
— Ben C., Cincinnati, OH

I would like to put all of these comics in the June monthly auction. I just sold similar copies of all of these books in your April auction and was happy with the results, so I hope to continue doing the same most months going forward! Thanks for the great service!
— Adam A., Fairfax Station, VA

More comics for you to buy! Opened another one of my "ancient" boxes, sealed since the 1980s. Had a bunch of UK Captain Britains in it. All are unread file copies with fairly minor storage flaws.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

Just wanted to say this is my third transaction with you, and it has been great doing business with you!
— Bryan B., Round Lake, IL

I know we just finished one trade deal with you, but as I continue liquidating, your system helps me get boxes moved in a timely manner, and this time, the trade value will help me fill in gaps in the collections of several friends!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

You guys are awesome.
— Charles D., Sanford, FL

When I've got a moment, I'm going to rave about you over on Trustpilot - you're the best! Hippity hoppity!
— Brett G., Miwaukee, WI

Hi, Thanks for making my first transaction super-easy. Here's round TWO!
— Shawn F., Los Angeles, CA

I'm happy to find a home for my magazines. Online recording was very easy! I have no experience in grading comics but will trust your judgment.
— Emily K., Pittsburgh, PA

Hi Buddy and the gang, I've always had the best experience with you all. Thanks for that over the years. It really does make transactions so much easier when they're based on professionalism and honesty.
— Mark S., Long Beach, CA

I haven't read a comic for 55 years. It's amazing how much they've changed. I picked up about 1,100 in a local auction and am working my way through them. They must have come from a comic book store that closed down. I've gone through about half so far, but will have more for you soon.
— Dan S., Sequim, WA

Cheers and thanks for the online trade credit.
— Carl S., Shelburne County NS, Canada

Cleaning out some of my graphic novels (to make room for new stuff) - found your site online, excited to find a resource easier than eBay!
— Christopher B., Rancho Santa Margarita, CA

I love your trade service where I can trade to you the comics I no longer want, in one or several transactions, and then use the credit for things I do want, including DC HC Absolutes, Omnibus, and Deluxe books. Thank you so much.
— James B., Owatonna, MN

While I'm on spring break, I am going to attempt to send you 1,200 comics! Saw the Batman Superman movie and as a DC fan enjoyed it.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

This is my first time selling comics to you. I really like the ease of your online service and am happy to keep sending my old comics your way.
— Travis M., San Antonio, TX

Hey! First time selling on your site. I recently came across my old comics from the 70's and up. Now the wife is making me sell them! I tried my best to grade them, but I've never done it before, so I hope I was accurate. Thanks for a selling site like this, guys, you made selling comics a lot easier!
— Reed L., Andover, NJ

My son is a third generation collector from Santa Cruz. I recently retired and have organizing what we believe to be 50,000 comics. I still remember when his father convinced me that we should buy a funny book called Fantastic Four #1 for 25.00 dollars at a county fair in 1969. My son still has that comic! He buys entire collections for one or two books and is running out of space. Most of the books are in terrific condition, unopened in most cases. Condition, condition, condition he tells me. He has purchased comics from you guys for the past several years and has even met "Buddy" at conventions. He says you are the best. And so far your service has been amazing. We are trying to find the most economical way to do this. We look forward to a continued relationship. My son has older and more valuable comics, Just let us know how we did on packaging and grading and we'll get it worked out. Thanks you guys!
— Laurie S., Aptos, CA

We have returned from our vacation and have received your cheque. I want to thank you and your colleagues for an AWESOME experience. Now that this first transaction has been great all around, I will be selling more comics. Thank you very much once again and hope to do business again very soon.
— Barry N., Ottawa Ontario, Canada

Thank you so much for your help! I feel that my trust was well placed and I believe that you gave me a fair price for my small collection on comics. You made it so easy by buying the lot. I sincerely wish you good fortune!
— Lee D., Madison, AL

Great system you have here. Thanks for the opportunity to sell my comics to you once again.
— Randy O., Nanoose Bay BC, Canada

Thank you for buying my comic collection. It has been my sincere pleasure to have conducted business with you. I hope our paths meet again in the not too distant future.
— Jeffrey M., Lexington, MA

My sister and I saved these comics from our childhood 70 years ago. Fun looking through them again. I'm including some which I could not find in your listing. What an excellent website you have, with great cover pictures!
— Burton M., Littleton, CO

I am completely blown away by the amazing offerings you have. Your recent move to foam corners in the packaging was brilliant, as was the cardboard protective packaging cut to the shape of a comic title divider. Pure genius.
— Sean P., Snoqualmie, WA

Here are a few more comics to sell really quick with the help of your wonderful company.
— Richard M., Reno, NV

Really enjoyed using your website. It is easy to navigate.
— Kevin B., Tallahassee, FL

I have had these comic since my childhood, but don't know much about comic grading, so I will trust you to give final grading. I want them to go to someone who appreciates them.
— Bob S., Lewis Center, OH

Third shipment coming, gents. This one a little bigger than the previous two. Mixed grades once again, but slowly improving overall. Thanks for your honest grading and comments. Cheers.
— Randy O., Nanoose Bay BC, Canada

Thanks, as always! It has been too long since my last trade in - at least a couple of months :)! Thank y'all SO much for allowing me the opportunity to trade these items! I can't tell you how much I truly appreciate it!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thank you for continuing to provide great service! Very fair grading, fast turnaround, and your shipping methods are among the best I've seen. I look forward to our future transactions.
— Frank G., Vista, CA

Thanks, guys 'n' gals! You are the best!
— Sarah H., Southington, CT

I have been buying and selling at this site for some time, and have been extremely satisfied with the service. More so now since I participated in my first auction and won!
— Oscar A., Los Angeles, CA

I've been buying and bidding with you guys for over two years now. Great customer experience, so now I'm ready to try selling via your consignment option.
— Rafael C., Benito Juarez District, Mexico

Shopped with MCS several times (with great convenience and success, thanks lads!), but first time selling. I'm just cleaning up my library before moving day, but if all goes well, I'll definitely do this again! Seems like buying and selling with the MCS site are both super handy!
— Michael A., Kamloops BC, Canada

Buddy, I received the last installment yesterday and would like to thank you for your prompt payment. I would also like to thank you and your wife for the assistance you gave me in catching my flight home. It has been pleasure doing business with you and Lone Star Comics over the years and I hope you will continue to prosper in the future.
— William Q., Sun City, CA