Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

My gracious thanks to all the workers there. Pickers and packers and graders. What great jobs they do. Thanks.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

Hey guys, this is my first transaction selling comics to you. I love buying from you guys and I'm sure I'll love selling also. I did my best on grading and tried to use your suggested grading for a start point. Looking forward to more business with your company. Thanks!
— Stanley M., Topeka, KS

Well, it's been a few weeks since my last trade so there is a LOT on your want list that I have. Here are the ones that think I can spare now :). As always, I truly appreciate it! Thanks!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

First time user and seller. Dig the service.
— Jesse V., La Cross, WI

Here's another lot for which I want a cash offer. I did several transactions with your store about a year or so ago and was very pleased with the speed and cash paid. I felt that everything was very fair. Thank you for that!
— Jennifer C., Lexington, IN

Thank you for affording me the opportunity to sell my comics. I have had them since I was a kid and now in you I have found a place to share them with people who are serious collectors.
— August C., Big Bear City, CA

This is my second time selling to you. Once in a while I've got to force myself to let go of parts of my collection, either for space or financial reasons, and your site is very convenient to use. Searching for issues is always spot on and the tips for identifying issue variants are always available with details. It really is a pleasure to buy and sell from such an organized company! Thank you and I hope you enjoy checking in and grading this batch!
— Christopher V., Norwalk, CT

Thank you for making the selling process straightforward and easy!
— Michael N., Stoneham, PA

Okay, not my first time, but over time I've begun to more deeply appreciate your going the extra mile to offer people options to buy/sell to/from you or others via store credit, cash, auction, and consignment. Every policy/rule/procedure I've encountered actually makes sense to me as necessary because of quantities, business flow, and fairness. (As a retired litigation attorney who used to represent businesses, my praise in this context is not earned unless fully merited.) Your staff have been unfailingly helpful, too! Keep up the good work. Speaking of which, here's another proposed sale list for y'all to work on. :) Cheers!
— Joan M., Seattle, WA

Your web site is the MOST USER FRIENDLY comic site I ever seen! This is my very first time selling comics to you, but I have been using your site since 2011 to fill in my back issue runs and, especially when prepping for a convention, looking for specific issues for artists or writers to sign, etc. Thanks to you all, I was able to complete my Marvel Shogun Warriors collection as well as the Marvel Godzilla run. Keep up the great job.
— Stephen F., Mesquite, TX

I have a few friends that have had great success using your consignment services. This is just a small batch of some doubles I had. I had heard enough positive things from my associates that I figured I might as well get the ball rolling. Expect more books from me!
— Robert D., Dunwoody, GA

I love that I can trade my comics for more to read - that's great. That being said, I'm not sure I scored these all correctly. Some may be in better shape than I indicated, and some may not be as in good a shape as I thought. I'm not new to reading comics, but I am new at grading them - please be patient!
— Keith B., Cleveland, TN

I am the owner of a comic book store and I have a lot of overflow I'd like to sell. Starting with one long box.
— Jason C., Maynard, MA

I acknowledge that I am not experienced at grading and so I may be off-base on some (or many) of the items. Based upon your high marks given by past customers, I trust you to grade appropriately, and will accept your advice on this. Your website is exceptional and represents considerable effort on your part!
— Marshall D., Belmont, MA

First time doing business with you. You were highly recommended by a friend.
— Andrew M., Bowie, MD

I recently purchased 6 comics from you for a total of $330 with my trade credit. I gave these comics as gifts to 6 recent college graduates that I know. They were a HUGE, and unique, hit!!!!! Thank you.
— Brian D., Chalfont, PA

Love your site!
— Will M., Pleasanton, CA

Regarding the comics I am selling to you, thank you for the yellow flagged items that indicate a significant offer price reduction below a given grade. I reviewed them and accept the risk of lower grading. I'm excited to learn what my overall grading accuracy rate is so I can learn and do better next time. I've still got boxes and boxes of comics to go through and submit for sale. Cheers!
— Joan M., Seattle, WA

Thanks, I love doing Business with you!
— Nikki C., Evandale, OH

Thanks again for your fast and fair trade assessment! It's a blast doing business with you guys!
— Brett G., Whitefish Bay, WI

I would just like to say that I'm so happy that I found someone that will actually pay me something good for my comics.
— Samm M., Fort Myers, FL

You guys are great!
— Adam G., Waldoboro, MN

I always look forward doing comic book trades with you guys! Thanks for the opportunity!
— Brett G., Miwaukee, WI

You made the first two transactions so easy and pleasant! Thank You!
— Rachel H., Timmins Ontario, Canada

It has been awesome working with you and putting some of my stuff up for consignment.
— Josef J., North Bergen, NJ

Please do set my consignment account to "cash equivalent credit." I am looking forward to using this "cash equivalent credit" when I see something in the auctions that I would like. You are always a pleasure to deal with, and I am so grateful for your unending help.
— Chuck W., Lake Buena Vista, FL

Wanted to say thanks for everything regarding the auction of my Green Lantern #87 9.8. I'm really happy with the price achieved. You should be getting a steady stream of decent stuff from me this year.
— Sam C., Goodwood, South Australia

Honestly, I'm just trading in comics for more credit to get other comics I've wanted for some time. I really love your guys any your selection!
— Jerrod R., Morgantown, WV

Thanks, guys, for the fair shakes as always, regarding my comic trading with you. :)
— David S., Montreal, Canada

Excellent website design for both buying and selling. It's appreciated.
— William C., San Diego, CA

I am so old that I am pre-TV, pre-Sputnik, pre-computers, pre-internet BUT NOT pre-comics or electricity - hope this wasn't too personal, but I do love Lone Star Comics.
— Jordan N., Chico, CA

Love you guys!
— Bryan W., Austin, TX

Thanks for a great system that allows me to streamline my collection as I need to!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

Hi Buddy, Thanks for buying my comics. It was a pleasure to do business with you and the great state of Texas!
— Fred H., Arnold, MD

Got another comic trade coming your way. Ya'll are awesome!
— Bryan W., Austin, TX

I've been collecting comics in earnest for about four years now, mostly trying to collect all X-Men comics (using trades where possible). Over time I've come up with dupes and other issues I just don't need, and I'm real glad to be able to get credit from Mycomicshop so I can fill some gaps and be able to buy issues when I need them!
— Jesse T., Springfield, OR

Thanks Buddy! Your site is the best!
— Michael S., North Bend, WA

I've heard great things about your website on the Comic Book Collecting Facebook group, but this is my first transaction with you. Once I receive my credit for these issues, I will be making my first purchase from you, and it will definitely include some of my own money above and beyond the credit I'll receive for the comics I'm trading.
— Stephen B., Lansing, MI

Looking forward to another great transaction. Thanks for making the process for selling comics so seamless.
— Chris T., Foster City, CA

Hi guys - always a pleasure to do business with you!
— Tony L., Chicago, IL

Hey guys, great website! This site makes buying and selling very convenient.
— Taylor B., Portville, NY

I visited your website for the first time and spent a couple of hours over the weekend looking over your awesome pre-order service. Love having a the catalog right there. My first time having any dealings with Mycomicshop, and I hope, based on the sub service, I can become a new customer.
— Matt F., National City, CA

I love your system. This has been the easiest method of selling my comics I've found.
— James F., Potomac Falls, VA

You guys are great and your website is the best. Love doing business with you!
— Eric G., Los Angeles, CA

I wanted to sell my comics, but I didn't know where. I searched the internet and came across your company. I read lots of great reviews so I decided to give it a try, and I'm so glad I did. Thanks for buying my comics.
— Betty W., Albany, GA

It's been a pleasure doing business with you. Thank you for providing an honest trading venue.
— Germaine H., Phoenix, AZ

If the comics I graded are wrong for some reason, don't send back just re-grade. Your grading will be fine with me. Some of my friends have used your sight already and said you are fair. Thanks.
— Mark W., East Meadow, NY

I have been collecting comics since 1978 after watching The Incredible Hulk on TV beginning with Hulk #221. I was a customer of Lone Star Comics back in the early 80's and I visited your store on East Abram Street in Arlington in 1981 during a family trip to Six Flags Over Texas. I bought Fantasy Masterpieces #1 for $5 back then and it was, at the time, the oldest book I owned. And I still have it. On a subsequent trip in 1984, I bought Fantastic Four Annual #3 (wedding of Reed and Sue). I still have both of them. I also bought the paperbacks "Origins of Marvel Comics" and "Son of Origins" in the slipcase and received a Marvel Mini-Book, Minnie the Model (the "smallest comic ever made") as a bonus for buying that slipcase set. Thanks for reviewing my comics for sale.
— Christopher B., San Antonio, TX

This website is very well organized and easy to use. Thanks for the convenience! I will definitely be a return customer.
— Katie G., Seattle, WA

Thanks, you guys are fair every time!
— Sean T., Livonia, MI