Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

This is my second time selling comics to you. You make it so easy to clean out the extras in my collection! Thanks!
— Anastasia P., New York, NY

I've dealt with you all before so I trust your grading. Most of these I went with the "suggested" grade. I do think quite a few will grade higher than suggested, but won't know until I crack open the boxes. Anyway, I am confident you will be thorough and fair as always.
— Vince S., Sheridan, WY

Thanks for another successful comic trade. You have a great selection of Simpsons comics.
— Ethan E., Clinton, OK

My roommate spoke very highly of his entire transaction experience with you. He said that from start to finish the whole process was excellent. I'm grateful for mycomicshop.com giving me the opportunity to sell my graphic novels. You seem to have integrity as a business and I respect that. I want to do business with a company like yours. Thank you!
— Ophir K., Woodland Hills, CA

Thanks for your service. It makes selling fast and easy. With the downturn in the economy and having been unemployed for a year, the time has come when I have had to make sacrifices and unfortunately sell my comics. Your service has made it easier to expedite the process.
— Phil Q., Rossville, GA

Great to make another sale so soon. Good for me and you.
— Ethan E., Clinton, OK

I love your site and can't wait to be able to record my comics with you. It is an easy site to navigate. I am very impressed with the way you pack and ship my orders.
— James C., Pine Bluff, NC

Your web site is great!
— Jeremy F., Waynesboro, PA

I just submitted a transaction Monday, and it's already Wednesday, so let's start another one! It is SO nice how your want list is constantly updated, so I can consistently offer books to you. Thank you so much.
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Great site!!!
— Jess Z., Earlville, IL

These are comics from my personal collection. I've been collecting since middle school. My oldest son is going to go to college in a year and I need to start selling off my rather large collection. I've sold stuff on eBay over the years. This is the first time I've tied dealing with you all. Someone recommended via twitter that I try selling to you.
— Brad B., Potomac, MD

After sorting through all my boxes of comics and shipping off several boxes to Lone Star Comics over the past month, I'm coming close to running out of stuff worth selling. Lots of work, but it's been fun.
— Matthew H., San Antonio, TX

I've been collecting comics since I was a kid, but this is my first time selling any of them. I'm thrilled that you've made it so easy to figure out how to do that. I've been really happy with the orders I've placed with you when buying comics, too. Keep up the good work!
— Adam J., Orem, UT

No problem and thanks! Nice to see the AF 15 sold today! Also, I met with another seller today and told him all about mycomicshop.com and how great you guys are! Just entered another consignment order today and have books on the way back from CGC and PGX that I will be sending in soon!
— Dave B., Clemmons, NC

Thank you again for having such an amazing system for selling and trading comics!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

Thanks for the great business opportunity you are providing for those of us wanting to trade or sell our comics.
— Ethan E., Clinton, OK

You guys are great! Loved the last stuff you sent me! God bless you all!
— Carl S., Fort Wayne, IN

Glad to find you folks, as it seems that you have the most reasonable and respectful approach to buying comic books.
— Keith M., Efland, NC

Buddy, I am so happy I found you guys to sell my collection to. I just finished my first Cash-in-a-Flash transaction with you, but I've also sent you more than 80 other sale lots. Regarding the Cash-in-a-Flash, Shane was great the whole way, answering my emails and being very professional. You guys rock. I will be recommending you to my friends who have big Golden and Silver Age collections, just as I was recommended to you by another one of your customers. I didn't try you at first because I thought you guys were a sister company of Mile High Comics, who I won't do business with. When my friend told me you weren't connected with Mile High, I sent in my first batch of books to you and couldn't have been happier with the results. You guys are very fair graders and, again, Shane is a great manager and takes care of his customers. Looking forward to many more transactions with you guys.
— Judith S., Coral Gables, FL

First timer trading with you. I have a work associate who shops at your site and speaks highly of you.
— Davey C., Lakewood, NJ

I traded with mycomicshop quite a few times years ago and was always more than satisfied. Well, I got swept up in the business of life and took a break from comics for a while. Now easing my way back into my old cherished hobby and no better way than to get back in the swing of things than with mycomicshop.
— Anthony S., Bronx, NY

Thanks again! You guys are the best. I am excited to see how all these books sell at auction, especially the Hulk #181.
— Marc T., Fort Walton Beach, FL

I am so glad I found this site! I look forward to a long-term relationship with you. I was an avid collector in the 90s and kind of stopped cold-turkey, looked around, and saw boxes of comics just staring at me! I moved from New York, NY to Laughlin, NV, and now I reside in Vicksburg, MS, all the while towing all the comics with me wherever I've lived! I have been wanting to do this for ages, but just now just decided to hunker down and get it done! Thanks from a very happy "first-timer"!
— Michelle K., Vicksburg, MS

This is my first time submitting comics to you for trade. I just placed my second order earlier this week after being very impressed with the first one. Everything looked great and was packaged incredibly well. Please let me know if I mis-graded anything. Thanks you!
— Mike M., Powell, OH

You guys have the best prices on the web! Hope you guys can care for my comics as much as I do! Nuff said!
— Nolan S., Scottsdale, AZ

I'm ultra excited to do business with you again! I will arrange the comics I'm selling in the order provided for easier grading. Thank you!
— Adam P., Salem, NH

I chose the highlighted grade for each of the comics I'm selling rather than grading each one. I'm usually very pleased with how each batch of comics are graded and with the final offer.
— Josh R., Evansville, IN

This is my first time trading comics. I really enjoy your website and all it brings. It is awesome! Thanks for everything.
— Shea M., Boise, ID

I was excited to discover your website and to speak to a customer service representative. The whole process was fun. Now that I'm selling my comics, I hope someone else will enjoy my comics as much as I have.
— Jonathan S., Toledo, OH

I just want to congratulate you on the wonderful website you have. It is easy and simple to use. I just started selling books to you about a month ago and I have done many transactions with you already. I am happy with the service and the prices I got. I look forward to doing a lot more business with you. Thanks.
— Rene L., Coral Gables, FL

As always, I look forward to doing business with you.
— Robert J., Viera, FL

Hi Matt, Just wanted to send a quick note to say thank you for all your help with my consignment. I am really happy with the price that the Amazing Spider-Man #194 9.8 achieved. It has been a great experience, and you and your staff have been terrific. The final price was the icing on the cake! I have some more books that I would like to consign in the near future, so I will be sure to contact you when I am ready. Thanks again mate, you take care.
— Sam C., Goodwood, South Australia

Mr. Saunders, thank you for your consideration. Outstanding service from you (and Shane, as well) is why I continue to do business with Lone Star Comics.
— Joshua Z., Mentor, OH

I like your website and your stores.
— Matt J., Barry, TX

Easy to use system. Thanks!
— Joseph R., East Greenbush, NY

You are doing a great job! I couldn't be more pleased with my results. Here is another batch for your July auction. Thanks.
— Richard W., North Grafton, MA

It has been a while since I've sold to you guys, but since I had such a great experience the first time, I am doing it again. I have to unload some of my comics as I am moving to Maine in a couple of weeks. I hope you can find these books a good home. Take care and thanks!
— Evan G., Orlando, FL

I have sent you over 20 comic trade and sale lots. I am very pleased with your honesty in grading the books, and in the prices you offer.
— Oscar A., Bell, CA

Great selection and fantastic prices! Very reasonable buying rates as well! I'll recommend you to others for certain.
— Tom S., Albany, NY

Buddy, Here's another batch of comics for trade credit. Thanks!
— Fred M., Holland, OH

Thanks again, Buddy! I am selling this lot to help pay for my daughters first car. First you help me pay for her first year in college and now a set of wheels. What next, a wedding or a house? Glad to know a company I trust is helping us through these important stages. Even if you guys are Texas Ranger fans. :)
— Phil H., Corona, CA

Great site. Thanks for buying my comics. You're great!
— David E., Gastonia, SC

I am constantly amazed that I can morph my extra comics into comics gold. Thank you for all the people I can give comics to with this credit.
— James S., Boxboro, MA

I have traded with you guys several times in the past and have always found you to be fair in your grading.
— Scott G., Hurst, TX

Thanks again for making your trading process as easy as it is. I tried to grade my comics conservatively so I hope I didn't over-estimate too many of them this time! Thank you!
— Glenn S., Enfield, CT

You guys rock! Best site on the net!
— Carl S., Fort Wayne, IN

I love you guys. Swapping comics back and forth with you is something I genuinely enjoy doing. Thanks for making it so easy to do.
— Tucker S., Brooklyn, NY

This is my first time dealing with the selling part of your website. I recently made a few purchases on your site and loved everything about it so I thought I would give this a go. Thank you.
— Chris W., Adamsville, TN

Third time's the charm. Pleasure doing business with you.
— Daniel R., Dallas, TX

Thank you for double checking the grading on my Daredevils. Your grading really makes me have faith you as a fair trader.
— Alex S., Kenosha, WI