Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Our Selection

Love your selection! I’m close to completing my Wonder Woman run and you’ve been very helpful in finding issues I’m missing!
— Tawnni J., Salt Lake City, UT

Howdy, MyComicShop! Thank you so much for listing the FCBD 2025 comics. Of course, I had to order more for me and my family. Thanks again for the most excellent care you show in packing and shipping. Y'all are the best! Have a MARVELous day. Excelsior!
— Raymond E., Nacogdoches, TX

Great selection, as always!
— Steve B., Golden, CO

Thank you as always. You guys seriously have the best inventory I've ever seen!
— Ramon C., Aledo, TX

Happy Spring to everyone at MyComicShop! Thank you for the continued great selection of wonderful comics and your world class packaging!
— Shawn D., Whitestone, NY

The best in comic book titles and availability, and all at great prices for all comic book collectors and fans. 5 STARS!
— Dennis B., Flushing, NY

Always a pleasure to deal with your store! Great selection, great pricing, great care in the shipping of the issues... what more could a person really want?! Keep up the terrific work!
— Bob M., Sarnia, Canada

I just wanted to take a moment to reach out and thank you folks for always providing an outstanding customer experience. I’ve been a customer of MyComicShop for about five or so years now. While I might be considered “newer” in the grand scheme of things, I’ve become a loyal customer, and for good reason. Every order I’ve placed has arrived without a hitch, and the packaging is consistently top-notch, and far better than other places (including the way CGC ships books back). The care and attention that goes into each shipment never goes unnoticed. Also, your selection is phenomenal. I’ve been able to track down some elusive issues I thought I’d never get my hands on. I’m not usually someone who leaves reviews or writes in, but I’ve just been so consistently impressed that I felt it was worth saying: more businesses could learn a lot from how you operate. It’s clear that everyone there cares about doing things right, and it shows. Thanks again for everything. You’ve earned a customer for life.
— Anthony R., Louisville, KY

Many thanks - no better back issue source than you guys!
— Jeffrey M., Fort Wayne, IN

I love the old affordable fanzines and comics. Thanks again!
— Jerry L., Duncan, OK

I have been a steady customer of MyComicShop for probably at least eight years now, and that is because I appreciate your quality merchandise and service very much.
— John F., Rutherford, NJ

Many Thanks for always having the exactly what I’m missing, be blessed and stay safe!
— Lx B., Stuart, VA

I can't say enough good things about this site...great selection, fair prices, and excellent support staff...keep up the good work team!!
— Dardo S., East Rockaway, NY

Happy Spring to everyone at MyComicShop! Thank you for the continued great selection of comic books!
— Shawn D., Whitestone, NY

Excellent, outstanding online comic book shop! Where would the world be without this fantastic shop and their extensive back catalog? Thanks again and take care!
— Carl J., Santa Cruz, CA

Just wanted to say that I really appreciate you guys! I'm new to comic collecting and have been looking for some of these stories that have been just so hard to find anywhere else and I'm so grateful that I'm able to find them here at such good prices!
— Fayelynn S., Lakewood, CO

Thanks for the great back issue stock. Makes collecting a breeze!
— Logan C., Cedar City, UT

You folks are great. Thanks for great selection at great prices!
— Freddy S., Summerville, SC

Awesome deals and selection!
— Christopher D., Cohoes, NY

Thanks for the great discounts and selection!
— Ivan H., Richmond, CA

Thanks for having a great selection!
— Thomas N., Manchester, NH

This is my first time ordering from MyComicShop. I was recommended by my friend, who had high regards towards your service and collection. Just wanted to say thank you!
— Amrik S., East Elmhurst, NY

So many great books, I needed to make another great order!
— John E., Kennesaw, GA

Woohoo! I love this site! MyComicShop always has everything I want to order.
— Marc T., Ashland, OH

Prices are amazing here; keep up the good work. This shop is my go-to for vintage comics my local shop doesn't have or has overpriced.
— Adam L., Asheboro, NC

Thanks again for the awesome selection, speedy delivery, and easy-to-navigate services. See you again soon!
— Mike G., Rincon, PR

My name is Henry and I received my order today. Everything was in order and exactly what I purchased. Today’s delivery completed my collection of Iron Man Vol. 1. Thank you guys for helping me reach this goal. I have purchased many of the issues from you over the past few years. This collection is a bit more special than most. As a child I suffered a great deal of abuse at home. The Iron Man character and his stories got me through some dark times. I always dreamed of one day owning every copy. Growing up in the 1980s it was much easier and cheaper to try and accomplish. I got close around the time the first volume ended. I would unfortunately lose my entire collection shortly after, when I left home. I could not bring myself to pick up a comic book for almost 20 years. The pain of my loss and what it meant was too much. Then one day my wife and I had a son. It wasn’t long before I was sharing my former love of Iron Man and comic books with my son. My son had reawakened something that I thought was long gone. Over the past 10 years my son and I have pieced together this collection. Countless hours going through boxes of comics in old warehouse. We even made it to a few old school comic book shows held in hotel ballrooms. We visited every comic book shop within 100 miles of our home. Today’s delivery contained the final missing issues. All 332 issues plus 15 annuals, done. 35 years from start to finish. Thank you guys so much. Every order I placed arrived early, as advertised and well packaged. Your company was able to provide me with many of the hard to find issues and in good condition. I’m not sure if I would have been able to finish without you guys. It would have certainly taken much longer. Sorry for taking so much of your time. This just really meant a lot to me.
— Henry S., Oviedo, FL

Thanks for having such a wide selection of old comics, and for packing them so carefully!
— Chuck W., Kissimmee, FL

First time using MyComicShop. You have an impressive list of comics available that a few other shops I've checked don't have!
— Gavin K., Leixlip, Ireland

Thank you for having these variant covers!
— Laurin D., Grand Rapids, MI

Thank you again for a great and fascinating selection!
— Wah W., Houston, TX

Thank you so much! You guys always have the comic books that I never dreamed I'd actually get to own!
— Paul A., Brighton, United Kingdom

Thank you all for your continued excellent service and quality product!
— Daniel E., Houston, TX

Thanks again! It's always easy to fill in the gaps in my collection with MyComicShop. Plus, I appreciate the extra care you take with packaging and shipping the comics. They always arrive in perfect condition. Thank you again!
— Wayne W., Miamisburg, OH

I can always find what I’m looking for. Keep up the great work!
— Freddy S., Summerville, SC

Excellent company and group of people. It is always great coming back to buy from MyComicShop.com, you guys have an outstanding selection of older comic book issues. Thanks again & take care!
— Carl J., Santa Cruz, CA

It's my first time ordering from your site, but my brother had great things to say after he found some Dark Knights Of Steel he had been hunting. Thank you for having such an incredible collection!
— Jacob S., Brooklyn, NY

You guys have an amazing selection of books, I'm kind of reliving my youth if you couldn't tell by the orders. keep up the good work and thank you!
— Mike D., Normal, IL

You guys have been my go-to as a new comic book reader. I appreciate the vast inventory and you always have what I need. Just wanted to say thank you!
— Jim R., Piscataway, NJ

I got way behind on buying comic books. I really appreciate how well you guys operate, gonna be catching up on Walking Dead Deluxe here soon thanks to you guys! I stopped collecting them at 42, but you guys have pretty much all of them in stock. Anyways, thanks fellars!!!
— Jamie B., Fort Worth, TX

Always great selection, speedy delivery. You guys are great!
— Ray V., Dixon, MO

Thanks again for having the books I want/need. I will be back for more!!!!
— Phil O., Roseville, CA

Thank you for having a robust collection and being a continually reliable source of fair prices!
— Dio A., McKinney, TX

Awesome selection as ever, perfect for helping me to fill in gaps in my collection. Many thanks and all the best!
— Terry A., London, United Kingdom

Love you guys! It’s always a pleasure finding those hard-to-find books on your site. Keep up the GREAT work and thank you for helping make the comic collecting world a better place!
— Jed P., Avondale Estates, GA

Happy Belated New Year to everyone at MyComicShop! Thank you for the continued fabulous selection of comics and competitive pricing! May you all find free time this Winter to enjoy your favorite comics!
— Shawn D., Whitestone, NY

Thank you for the selection and deals!
— Wah W., Houston, TX

Thank you for having this comic. I've been trying to complete my collection for ages.
— Marijke S., Somerville, TX

Thank you so much! I was able to find items here that I couldn't find anywhere else, and at such a great price too.
— Kaelyn H., Bloomington, IN

If you’re looking to purchase, or sell, comic books online, look no further than MyComicShop.com. Forget sellers on eBay, or other venues, who are probably charging inflated prices, and who might have multiple copies of a particular issue, but display only a photograph of the best copy they’ve got. If it’s old comics you’re looking for, their prices are extremely reasonable, and their grading of comic books is impeccable. If you’ve got a stash of comics you want to sell, they have an online “Want List” of comic books they’re interested in purchasing; and they go out their way to determine whether what you have is what they’re looking for, and whether they can offer you a fair price for them. They will e-mail or call you personally to try to work out the transaction. If you’re looking to buy, their inventory is so vast, I doubt there’s something in there I might want that they don’t have – or maybe could help me find.
— Mark L., Coventry, CT