Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

What can I say, I'm a romantic. Collecting comics when I was young meant trading books and stuff and talking about artists and characters and the whole thing. Your comic trading site feels very similar!
— Book S., Waterville, ME

Your Buy/Trade option is awesome, and puts Lone Star one step ahead of the others!
— Bob G., San Francisco, CA

First off I would like to say that your store/site is amazing. I have been able to find countless comics at truly reasonable prices (vs. eBay or sites with nothing much at all!). So thank you greatly for what you have done for the hobby. I just wish I knew about your site when I was stationed in Japan. Had I known, I wouldn't now be spending time playing catch up!
— Ashley M., Puyallup, WA

I've done one trade previously and enjoyed the superb service and communication. Again, thank you for running such an exceptional business--a business that is of service to the whole hobby.
— Ashley M., Puyallup, WA

As always, you guys are great. Thanks for taking in trade the stuff I don't want and giving me credit for the comics I do want.
— Daniel G., Salt Lake City, UT

Buddy, THANK YOU for such a fair offer. As in the past, I accept your offer and await the check. Again, your grading/pricing for the comics I have sent your company is exceptionally fair.
— Patrick D., Leesburg, GA

Buddy, Thank you again for such prompt service. Your offer for my World's Finest collection is more than fair. I ACCEPT it and await the check. As in the past, dealing with your company is a pleasure. THANK YOU.
— Patrick D., Leesburg, GA

I just wanted to say thanks for further enhancing how your system buys comics! Such an amazing tool! Thanks again!
— John K., Yuma, AZ

Thanks for my last trade. It is so nice to be able to swap out old comics for credit for new ones to read! Thanks!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Hi Buddy, This morning, about a half-dozen comics were already flagged for me in my cart before I even woke up! Yesterday I had zero (after completing a trade offer). Neat that overnight you needed these additional issues and that your system let me know.
— Howard M., Somerset, NJ

Hi Buddy, I left with an empty cart. Three hours later and I return to find $45 in credit just waiting for me. Not too shabby. Thanks, Howard
— Howard M., Somerset, NJ

Keep up the great work! Buying from you has been a wonderful experience. This is my third transaction since trading some of my books to you. Plus I still have credit left over. How can a guy hate that?!
— Greg H., Raleigh, NC

Your site is great. This will be my 2nd trade. I've been bouncing in and out of the comic book world for a couple years now and really wish I had stuck with it. Frustration got the best of me a few times because I was trying to buy everything that came out. What I want to do now is trade part of my current collection and use the credit to get caught up with Batman, my favorite character. Thanks again for not only having this trade service, but for having a great site.
— Mike M., Smyra, DE

I love the new system, I have everything I have organized out of my 70,000 trade/sale comics in my trade account right now and will continue sending trade offers. Mycomicshop is the best and I love being able to trade with you guys.
— Scott C., Lehi, UT

Not sure of grades so I entered in green shaded areas. Please grade and submit correctly. You have always been fair. Thank you.
— Joe C., Cedar Grove, NJ

Dear Buddy, Your offer sounds good. I appreciate your honest and detailed explanation that is always enclosed with each offer. It has been a pleasure dealing with you during this whole process and you can be assured that I will spread the word that you are the one to contact for the best service.
— Janet S., Martinez, GA

Thanks for you for the fast service. I look forward to doing more business with you in the future.
— Joel D., Elizabeth, NJ

Hi Buddy, I just received the second check for my Amazing Spider-Man collection that I sold you. Thanks for the fast payment and making this an easy and fun transaction.
— Keith S., Dothan, AL

Hi Buddy, We have received your check and will be banking it early next week. We in the interim are packing a much larger box to send to you.
— John M., Cape Town, South Africa

Dear Buddy, what follows is a heartfelt testimonial: I'm a true believer! I am officially a disciple of new buy/trade system--and will distribute pamphlets at airports to spread the new gospel of Buddy ASAP. The reason is simple--it just scored me cold hard cash (in this case credit) that I would not have otherwise realized today, if ever. Here are the verifiable specifics: I've had 49 copies of BATMAN #647 just waiting to be added to the want list. It's a good solid book, but it's just one issue out of the thousands I have waiting to also jump on the want list. Previously my option would have been to check every book on a daily basis to see if it was suddenly needed. This would have taken me about 50 hours per 24 hour day (never was good at math) to check all of my books, and even then, I might have missed the window. Well, I entered the book in Buddy's new system and today it showed, up moved over to the want list, and is already sitting in my buy/trade cart, all 49 copies! Thanks again Buddy, this skeptic has been converted.
— Howard M., Somerset, NJ

Thanks for the careful grading!
— David B., West Hartford, CT

Thank you again. You guys are incredible. The most honest and fair I have ever worked with.
— Carol M., Boise, ID

I love the new sell/trade system. I absolutely love it! (Nick has been with us as long as any seller, going back six years to when our first and very primitive, by today's standard, buy/trade system was first introduced.)
— Nick R., Charlotte, NC

Buddy, the new sell/trade system is as awesome as promised. Tremendous time savings. Thanks again!
— David P., Columbia, TN

Best site out there to order comics from! Great customer service.
— Brian R., Pittsburgh, PA

It was really easy selling stuff to you guys and getting credit. I love your variety so much--it makes filling in my collection a snap. Keep up the good work and I'll continue being a customer!
— Jason H., Estacada, OR

Thanks so much! I appreciate the feedback on each comic. It is great to do business with you!
— Art J., Lehi, UT

Buddy, As usual, I'm very happy with your offer and thus accept it.
— Joe L., Allen, TX

Check received! I'm very pleased with how this process works and will definitely recommend your service to friends and colleagues.
— Paul S., Southfield, MI

Thank you for making the trade process that much easier!! I love working with you guys and now the task is simpler than before! You rock!!!!!
— Greg A., Indian Harbour Beach, FL

Look forward to doing business again.
— Scot P., Conway, AR

You can be assured that I will spread the word about your honesty and excellent service. It really has been a pleasure dealing with you and your associates.
— Janet S., Martinez, GA

Yes, I inherited a collection from a co-worker who was at a loss what to do with it and I wasn't sure if it had anything of interest, as there was so many interesting titles, one-shots, independent, and underground stuff. Your site is the best for researching! This first batch will help out immensely so I thank you for the cash offer! Any subsequent offers I make I hope to take advantage of the trade opportunities, as you still have so much I need for my personal collection!
— Aaron C., Bartlett, TN

Wow, talk about service. I love this new buy/trade system. It is excellent. No more manually having to keep a list. No more spending hours paring down a want list to take to a comic show or shop. This is excellent. Many thanks.
— Daniel J., Riverton, IL

Dear Buddy, I got the check as promised. Thanks for being so honest and prompt.
— Robert M., Bristol, RI

Hi Buddy, Just FYI, I'm definitely having fun using the new system. As I get used to it, I'm becoming more and more enamored of it. Just thought you'd like to know. Off to the flea markets - where who knows what treasures await!
— Howard M., Somerset, JN

Much thanks, and warmest regards. Buddy, since my relationship with you has grown, and I've begun running classifieds in my local paper, I am really hitting pay dirt as far as locating older collections. They've all been DC up to now (except one), but without you, this would not have been possible. Thanks again!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Buddy, I LOVE the new sell/trade system! It sure makes my job a lot easier! :)
— Matthew P., Logan, UT

I'm looking forward to dealing with you all again. My first transactions (both buying and selling) were wonderful experiences. You are helping me hone my collection into a workable form! I didn't list any prices in group B. I believe you will deal with me fairly if you are interested in the books and your best offer will be more than fair!
— Aaron C., Bartlett, TN

Thanks so much for your quick processing and very fair offers.
— Boyd R., Dedford, TX

Thanks again for improving your trading system. I really like the addition of the CGC and PGX designations for trading purposes.
— Wilfred W., Camus, WA

I received an honest and fair price for the comics I submitted to Buddy Saunders.
— Robert M., Bristol, RI

Your new trading and selling system is outstanding. I plan to enter a large quantity of our store's inventory in the near future.
— Regan C., Ft. Wayne, IN

Hi, Thanks for a great service. I came across 3,500 books at a garage sale and haven't known what to do with them since. It's good to have an easy way to sell.
— Chris E., Honolulu, HI

Great new system, Buddy. Lets us use the site as an inventory resource as well as a trade tool. Well done again.
— Mark R., La Mirada, CA

You provide a great service and I'm anxious to trade with your company.
— Paul S., Long Beach, NY

Thanks! I appreciate the work that went into grading. Very fair offer.
— Mike P., Kirkland, WA

I think your offer is very fair and I am pleased to accept it. Thanks!
— William M., Shawnee, OK

Thank you for your offer for my comics. It is quite agreeable to me. I have one last small box to forward to you containing approximately 80 comics. Selling to you has been a great experience!!!
— Janet S., Martinez, GA

Another terrific job, and I anxiously await payment. I have been contacted regarding yet more comics. I'll let you know if I decide to go through with the purchase. Thanks again!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV