Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I accept your offer for my comics. Thank you. Very professional and well done. (sold a large Silver Age collection)
— Greg B., Arcadia, CA

Thanks a lot guys. Your offer and grading is a fair assessment. I'm glad my comics in your hands. Thanks again and have a good one.
— Brian M., Edison, NJ

I've had two very smooth trades with your company and I am very pleased.
— Gary K., Princeton, NJ

Thanks Buddy and company. Always great trading comics with you.
— Wade E., Yakima, WA

Having fun. In this newest batch, almost all comics are prior to 1981. Had to go back and read your online selling procedures. Next time I will not follow my spouses directions blindly.
— John B., Crestline, OH

Thank you so much for taking the time to further assist me with info on how your online buying stems operates. I'm getting pretty excited about this. I'm going to buy a long box today and see how much fills up one of those, and might use smaller ones after that. Thanks again!
— John K., Yuma, AZ

Thanks guys! I trust your grading and appreciate your quick and professional communications. :)
— Joel H., Springfield, IL

I am thrilled with the way you guys have handled my trade-ins. Always a pleasure.
— Brandon B., Sophia, NC

Thanks! Your online selling and trading option is great!
— Sarah L., Davis, CA

This submittal for trade is this time for a batch of my own comics. I love that I can use the excess of my old collections to fill in my new collections!
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Here's another batch of comics from a friend of mine who heard I was going to be sending some of my books in and wanted to piggyback on my shipment. She liked how well she was treated the last time I submitted some books for her. Even though many of her books were re-graded, she was still quite pleased with the overall process.
— David H., Alexandria, VA

Buddy, Thanks for making the sale of my comic books a "PAINLESS" process. Your company makes it so easy to get the comics to you, have the comics graded fairly, and have a fair price given for the books submitted. It is a scary process the first time anyone sends their collection to a company for grading and pricing. You guys make it PAINLESS. It is a pleasure doing business with you and Lone Star Comics. I look forward to doing ALL my future business with Lone Star.
— Patrick D., Leesburg, GA

Great, very easy to use web site and ordering/trading system. Looking forward to buying and selling more comics with you soon. Thanks!
— David B., West Hartford, CT

Thanks again for your generous offers on our comics. This last check basically paid for our hotel room for our upcoming vacation...and with gas prices as they are now...let's just say, had I had to have gone through the eBay process, I wouldn't have nearly been taken care of so quickly, efficiently and generously as we were with you folks at Lone Star Comics. I have my eyes on yet another collection of Batman Annuals. When I get back, I may buy them, knowing in advance what you'll pay me. You're online price system has usurped Overstreet as the "bible" of the industry--if you pay $20 for a book, I know that's what it's worth at wholesale! That's a comforting feeling to have. Thanks for helping us out on our trip...you helped make it possible. I thank you also for being a new friend.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Thanks again, Buddy and crew!
— Phil H., Carona, CA

Thanks again! I'm cleaning out and organizing and you guys are wanting what I got. Imagine my pleasure and surprise!
— Greg A., Indian Harbour Beach, FL

Word has gotten around! A co-worker of the flea market gentleman I told you about called today and asked if I were interested in buying his comics. I told him I'd be glad to check out what he has; I'll let you know if he's got anything worthwhile. Take care, and as always, much thanks. The feeling of having someone reputable to sell to at any time is, well, quite nice.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Thanks a lot! Your online buying and trading system is really GREAT!
— Margaret T., Anacortes, WA

Buddy, Another excellent offer. Thank you and I accept.
— Joe L., Allen, TX

Dear Mr. Saunders, I am sending you more comics today. I wanted you to know before I sent them out. Look forward to doing business with you again.
— Margaret D., North Quincy, MA

Your trade offer for my comic looks good. Thanks again for your help.
— Adam F., Newhall, CA

Buddy, Thanks to you, I was able to nab this collection. Your onine system made it possible for me to know in advance what you pay for specific issues. Once again, you've proven your value to average Joes like me. I think you'll be happy with the comics I'm sending--I know I was. I sent them out today. Thanks again!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Just want to say that everything you promised in your email you delivered. I did get two offers in Indy, and basically, these folks are not interested in buying any comics at a reasonable price. There offers were very low compared to your offer. I do plan to do more business with you.
— Terry R., Indianapolis, IN

I love your trade service and your selection.
— Wm. Eric D., Sarasota, FL

Thanks for the offer. I accept. I plan to send more comics in the next week or so.
— Terry R., Indianapolis, IN

Thanks a lot! I am beyond happy! You are certainly the best, most fair company I have ever done business with. Not just comic companies, but ANY company or business. Thanks!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thanks, Buddy. I appreciate your attention and will gladly give you all of my business in the future. I think James O'Barr was living in Detroit when he wrote the Crow series, and I remember how cool it was to talk to him at a small show here. Again, thanks for your attention and for the offer for my comics. I look forward to doing business with you again in the future.
— Steve S., Warren, AL

Wow! My second of four sales to you is complete, and I must say, it saddens me that I didn't find you before I wasted all that money with eBay and PayPal fees. I've recouped $200 from a collection I recently bought in just three short weeks, with more to come, and at an actual fair percentage of what they're worth. I would have been lucky to have gotten 99 cents on eBay out of some of the books you've paid over 10 bucks for. (And, if I wasn't lucky enough to get bids on the first go-round, there are those darned re-listing fees, not to mention the time consumption of placing an ad...). As you can tell, Lone Star Comics will always get the first offer on any future collections I acquire; and it's comforting to know if I can't afford the collection, you'll offer me a nice "finder's fee" as well. Buddy, yours is a pro outfit all the way around! THANKS!
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Offer looks good. Thanks guys!
— Steve W., Lubbock, TX

A pleasure doing business with you.
— Steve S., Warren, AL

Nice doing business with the great folks at Mycomicshop!
— Chase C., Madisonville, KY

I accept your offer for my comics. Highest regards.
— Jerry M., San Francisco, CA

Dear Buddy, I have been selling comics to you using your online option and have been quite pleased with the results. That being said, after I submit my last sell/trade list of comics on your want list, I still have more pre-1981 non-want list comics. I'll be using your "Option #1B" plan for these.
— Dorothy M., Omaha, NE

I wish I would have discovered Lone Star Comics ten years sooner. We have got to stop trading like this. I think we might have to start a traders anonymous.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

Dear Buddy, Yes, I accept your offer for my Superman #76. I have enjoyed the experience of working with your company. I feel you have been fair, and I also found the whole online selling process very easy to work through. Thank you.
— Gail S., Amherst, WI

Hi Buddy and crew, I can't believe how great your sell/trade process is. You are in Arlington, Texas--over 2,300km (1,500 miles) away from my home here in Canada and this was literally easier than visiting my local comic shop! Thanks so much! I will definitely be trading with you again.
— Murray R., Brooklin, Ontario, Canada

Dear Buddy, I did an internet search and found lonestarcomics.com. I was amazed at how quick-n-easy it was to sell my copy of Bulletman Mighty Midget comic. I was ultimately amazed at the value and your offer! Thank you for your friendly, informative customer service. When I have more comics to sell, I will be calling you again.
— Wanda G., Watkinsville, GA

We have been pleased working with you and will continue working with you. Your comic buying system is an easy process and you respond in a timely manner.
— Paul H., Corning, NY

Thank you, Buddy, for giving me the fair market value for my collection. Thank you and you staff for the great customer service—I’m glad to see that this kind of customer service still exists. Again, thank you.
— Charles F., Rio Rancho, NM

I am very happy with my previous trades. Thanks a lot for this great service!
— Mike A., Edenton, NC

Thank you very much for providing your trading services! Even paying a portion of the cost of shipping, trading is working out in my favor! Thank you so much for allowing me to trade my comics for new ones to enjoy!
— Sharon E., Hamilton, Ontario, Canada

Hi Buddy, The check arrived for the three Scribbly comics (#T040813567) in a timely manner. A very smooth and professional transaction. Your offer was very acceptable. Thanks again for such a pleasant experience. Have a great day.
— John N., Hobe Sound, FL

Yes, Buddy, your offer for my Superman comics is acceptable.
— Tom T., Hackett, AR

Hi folks, Long time buyer, first time trader! I've got quite a few other books that I'm still going through, but I figured I'd start small and see if I've done everything correctly. Looking forward to doing this--and then spending my credit on even more comics!
— Murray R., Brookline, Ontario, Canada

Thanks, Buddy, I appreciate that! You have always been fair with me, and now even when I haven't asked you to be. Have a great day!
— Matthew K., Missoula, MT

Buddy, I accept your offer for my comics
— B. F. T., Mt. Olive, AL

I was very pleased with our previous transaction, and would now like to free up some additional room by selling these comics as well. Thank you.
— Jan Z., Holland, OH

Buddy, I accept your cash offer of $588.77 for my 18 Golden Age comics.
— Dorothy M., Omaha, NE

Buddy, It was great to talk with you. It's good to finally meet a dealer who, when they say they buy everything, really means it. When I buy a comic collection, I just want to be able to recoup part of my money immediately for those comics I don't want for my own collection. To that end, I'll use Lone Star Comics as my exclusive "partner." From here on out, when I buy any pre-1980s (I don't buy after 1969), I'll ship anything I don't need to you. I'm excited to have "met" you, even if just over the phone.
— Gary M., Huntington, WV

Buddy and crew, Here is another box of comics for sale-trade: 10% trade, 90% cash.
— Phil H., Corona, CA