Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Hi Buddy, Your offer for my comics is fine. Many thanks!
— Faina D., San Francisco, CA

Yes, your offer for my comics is acceptable. I will send you the rest of my comics--three boxes--soon.
— Robert L., Las Vegas, NV

Love doing business with you! Keep up the great work!
— Matthew S., Decatur, TX

Thanks for another very fair and satisfactory transaction (20% credit/80%cash). I approve all details of this trade/sale.
— Wes H., Phoenixville, PA

Your trade offer for my T-transaction looks great! Thanks!
— Dan S., Asheville, NC

Hello Buddy, Yes, I will take online trade credit. I will also be happy to send yet another package next week. You have been gracious with trade credit. Thanks! I am happy I have been able to send you salable merchandise which I no longer require.
— Stan W., Buffalo, NY

I didn't attempt to grade my comics, but would say the vast majority fall in the G to VG range in accordance with your grading standards. Thought I'd leave the grading up to your experts. I have had good experiences with your company so I felt I could trust your judgment. I tried a local shop but his offer seemed a bit on the low side. I'm just trying to clear out copies I don't need and trade them for credit towards other issues I'd like to add to my collection. Hope to hear back soon. Thanks for your time.
— Mike K., Paducah, KY

Yes, I accept your offer and yes, I would like $27.00 of your cash offer converted to online credit (I just set up an account with your site).
— Doug C., Madison, WI

Hi Buddy, That offer sounds fine. Thanks for all the help! Much appreciated!
— Gary L., Lauderdale Lakes, FL

Thanks once again for being there. Being able to trade with you to fill the holes in my own sets is a real treat and with oil hitting $90+ a barrel, who wants to drive around from shop to shop looking when you and the mailman are filling the void.
— Jordan N., San Carlos, CA

Thanks Buddy, Your offer sounds good to me. Thanks so much for taking the time to grade my comics and make an offer.
— Susan B., Mabank, TX

Yes, I accept your offer for my fourth lot of comics.
— Dan B., Littleton, CO

The offer is great. I'll take the 100% credit. You guys are simply the best. I have packaged up another box of 130 more comics.
— Matt G., Glenn Allen, VA

Buddy, I'm definitely going to have to take the trade value this time around. Please credit my account.
— Joshua R., Aurora, CO

The MyComicShop trade and sell process is very efficient, convenient and streamlined. Thanks for a great online resource.
— Charlie T., Brookline, MA

I am interesting in selling or possibly trade this new batch. Please let me know what the different totals are for both trade and cash once you finish grading my comics. I really appreciated my first selling experience with you guys and look forward to a continued great selling/trading relationship.
— Joshua R., Aurora, CO

Dear Buddy, Thanks for buying my comics after our talk on the phone. It's a pleasure doing business with you and you will be the first one I talk to when I have more.
— Barbara M., Bayside, NY

Do you know if my trade will be checked in before Wednesday? I was hoping to use the password word sale to buy some things off of your website. Just have to say I love the new website. It is awesome and extremely easier to use.
— Matthew S., Decatur, TX

Hello Buddy, I accept your offer. Nice doing business with you again.
— John T., Edinburgh, IN

Hello Buddy, Your offer for my comics sounds good. I accept.
— Matthew D., Bayonne, NJ

I mailed in a box of comics to you yesterday that I am wishing to sell. I have heard many good things from other customers of yours, so I would like to thank you in advance for your fair and honest practices.
— Karen K., ,

I accept the offer. Appreciate your business and thank you.
— Daniel S., Buffalo, NY

Buddy, Thanks for the e-mail. You are some real stand up people.
— Matt G., Glenn Allyn, VA

Mr. Saunders, I accept your offer and appreciate you taking the time to analyze and grade my comics. I will forward the last two lists for your review as soon as they are completed.
— Terri S., Pikesville, MD

The offer looks good, Buddy, and I accept it. Thank you for processing the review and payment so quickly. Take care.
— Eric W., Benicia, CA

Your offer for my comics met my expectations and I am quite satisfied.
— Hans R., San Luis Obispo, CA

Thank you. Yes, I accept your offer for my recent comic lot.
— Robert S., Conroe, TX

Buddy, I'm delighted with your offer for my comics.
— Joe L., Allen, TX

I accept your offer of $1,156.20. Happy to do business with you.
— Ruth B., Kirkland, WA

Buddy, I've been really happy with the credit you've given me for the comics I've traded to you in the past and was equally happy with the Archies I received in trade. Up to now I've always sent issues that matched your want list, but this time I'm sending my remaining extras under your Option #1B terms. Whatever your offer, I'd like 100% credit applied to my account. I'll use that credit to fill in gaps in my Archie collection.
— Kyle H., Dallas, TX

Buddy, Wow! I can hardly wait to start using that online trade credit! I accept your offer. Thanks very much, as usual!
— Kyle H., Dallas, TX

Buddy, Please send the cash. I will have more comics on the way soon.
— Phil H., Corona, CA

Buddy, I accept your offer. You guys really are the most fair comic book shop hands down. I'll send all my books to you in the future.
— Joshua R., Aurora, CO

Just wanted to provide you with some feedback on my most recent order for Amazing Spider-Man #8 (1st series). The comic's condition was better than advertised and your free shipment program including tracking keeps me coming back for more! An added bonus is your Buy and Trade program that allows me to trade in comics to aid in my goal of acquiring the remaining 19 issues of Amazing Spider-Man (#1 - 544) that I do not yet own.
— Shawn P., Shenandoah, VA

Hello! OK, I have been sitting on the sidelines and watching for a long time. I'm going to jump in and give this a try. Your instructions say to give you an e-mail heads up with all my contact info....so here it is. I'm sending one long box with about 329 20 to 40 cent'ers, all for trade credit. I should get them out tomorrow. I look forward to hearing form you! Thanks!!
— Quinn M., Springfield, IL

Thanks again for your terrific service, both for the books you offer, and for your buy/trade system! I approve this trade/sale offer.
— Wes H., Phoenixville, PA

Hi, Thank you for the response. I accept the offer of $1,087.40 for my comics (including shipping rebate). And again, thank you.
— Eric D., Olathe, KS

I love you guys!
— Jon M., Irving, TX

Buddy, Thanks again for getting back to me. I have a great deal of early comics that I'd like to sell; the ones I sent you are just a small part. Your communication, regardless of the offer, shows me that you care about your customer contacts. I think I'm going to enjoy doing business with you and your company.
— Dan W., Somerville, NJ

Yes. I accept your offer on my fifth comic lot. More on the way.
— Robert S., Conroe, TX

Hello, I'm back again, this time with a batch of comics from my wife's friend, hence the reason why it is a cash transaction this time. I did not have the time to grade the comics--all I did was the data entry part for her. These books were part of her adult son's collection before he died and she has decided now that she can start to let him go. Thanks again for the ease of the process for selling/trading comics.
— Dave H., Alexandria, VA

Buddy, Just accepted your cash offer for my comics. Considering as how I'm not a professional, I didn't do to badly in my overall grading. To bad you don't have any job openings. That would be a lifelong dream for me to be around all that history! :-) Thanks Again Bob
— Bob M., Dodge City, KS

Thanks so much for your wonderful buying and trading service.
— Philip Y., Temple, GA

Thanks again for your prompt service and super customer-service support. I look forward to doing more business with you in the future.
— Sue S., Lakewood, OH

I accept your offer and thank you for your assistance and speedy reply.
— Clarence C., Houston, TX

Buddy, Thank you for the offer. It is acceptable.
— Felix K., Jacksonville, FL

Thank you, Buddy. Always a pleasure doing business with you!
— Ray R., Pasadena, MD

Buddy, I accept your offer for the comics I've sent you. Thanks once again.
— Jesse M., Thunder Bay Ontario, Canada

Thank you. I accept your offer.
— Robert S., Conroe, TX

Mr. Saunders, I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks!
— Keith R., Manassas, VA