Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

Buddy, Thank you for your response. I will accept your offer of $1,202.80 even though I was hoping for more in the range of $1,500, since I was offered $750 from a comic book store in my area. Again, thank you.
— Steve P., Harleysville, PA

Hey Guys, Here's another batch of trade comics I'd like to send your way!
— Graham G., Lawrenceville, GA

Hey Buddy, Thank you for the reply and helpful info on how you buy comics from sellers. I will try out your www.webuycomics.com site. You guys are great. I have bought a lot of books from you in the past.
— Mark P., Mt. Sinai, NY

Tomorrow I'm sending you another box of comics for an offer. I've sold you comics a few times in the past and was always happy with the results. Thanks.
— Jordan L., Marietta, OH

I am very happy with my purchase. All my issues came just as described. I'll be pleased to do business again with you again real soon-- you know, read'um once for the story, then trade 'um for more stuff to read. It has been nice doing business with you.
— Ben G., Grandbury, TX

I accept your offer for my third lot of comics.
— Dan B., Littleton, CO

One of my favorite weekend activities is reviewing your want list for comics that I can send in for trade credit. I was wondering how often your want list is updated? Thanks for your time. (Buddy replies: Good question, Joel. We update literally minute-by-minute 24-hours a day every day. However, once we approve your comics to ship, your items can't be bumped off our buy/trade list even if they do go off the online want list.)
— Joel P., Milford, OH

I received the communications from you and your staff regarding my credit and cash. Thank you very much! You guys were great to work with and very flexible. I appreciate doing business with you. Now to search through my comics to see if I have anything else I'm ready to trade thruough your buy/trade system. Enjoy your summer!
— Sean B., Exton, PA

Buddy, Your offer sounds reasonable. I accept.
— Kevin F., Metuchen, NJ

Buddy, The offer looks good. Thanks.
— Aaron H., Jefferson, WI

Your offer sounds good to me. I accept.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

Buddy, The offer for my comics is fine. I am still sorting comics and should soon have another shipment to send. I will work on getting more comics out to you. Thanks.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

I have sent books to you guys before and was always happy with the fast, friendly service. Thanks for everything!
— Lisa S., Tampa, FL

I accept your offer for my 347 comics lot. Thanks!
— Janegail O., New York, NY

Thank you. Your offer for my two boxes is good to go.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

Thanks as always. MCS rocks the house!
— Rick S., Melbourne, FL

YOU'RE GREAT!!! I accept your offer.
— John G., Yuma, AZ

Buddy, Thanks for the offer which I accept. You are a gentleman. It is a pleasure to speak to someone who is kknowledgeable and pleasant. I will put an order in with my credit soon and I will be sending more comics in a few weeks.
— Billy S., Columbia, TN

Hello Everyone, and particularly Adam L.(who checked in my books, I recently completed my first "Trade/Sale" transaction with you at Lone Star, and I want to give you high credits for making this exactly as easy and smooth as advertised. I'll admit that initially, since all the books I sent in were not all graded in the condition I thought they might have been, I was a little perturbed, so I requested a couple sent back so I could take another look, and sure enough, upon a more intensive review, I could see that I was a little lax in my grading standards. This will serve me well in grading future dealings with you and any others in the future. Thanks very much for the slap upside my head!! ^_^ Thanks, I needed that!! Sometimes you have to be cruel to be kind! I very much look forward to future transactions with you, and thanks for your very excellent service!
— Wesley H., Phoenixville, PA

I accept your offer for the comic lot I sent you. Please send "cash in a flash" after deducting the proper amount.
— Sam C., Poughkeepsie, NY

Buddy, Your offer for my comics is fine.
— Tim F., Patterson, NJ

I appreciate you helping me (your trade system) clear out some room in my collection...now it's time to buy more comics.
— Donald H., Chapel Hill, NC

I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks.
— Robb H., Jonesborough, TN

Hi Buddy, Received your offer and spoke with my sister. The offer is acceptable. I will start working on the next "installment" of comic for your appraisal. Thanks for your help.
— Francis S., Easton, MD

Buddy, Thank you. I see now that I was confusing two different shipment. Your offers for both are fine. By the way, I am going to be sending out a couple more boxes of Silver Age DC for another offer from you.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

I'm sending in about 2-3 long boxes with all the orders I have pending with you right now. Thanks for being a great company to trade with. (Scott is up to 55 buy/trade transactions with us)
— Scott C., Lehi, UT

Buddy, I love your site and trade works good for me since there are things I want to buy from mycomicshop.com. You run the best comic business I've ever done dealt with and I truly mean that. It's also always a pleasure doing business with you.
— Mike B., Logan, WV

The offer for my comics is good. Thanks.
— Bert S., San Diego, CA

Once again, you have a fast and friendly service, and your buy/trade is very fair.
— Keith N., St. Augustine, FL

Your offer sounds good, Buddy. Thanks again.
— Alex S., East Meadow, NY

Hi Buddy, Wow, you folks are fast! The trade offer looks very fair to me. Thanks for going thru all of that less-than-stellar condition stuff. Thanks again and take care.
— Scott A., Lincoln, NE

I accept your offer for my comics.
— John C., Bozeman, MT

I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks again!
— Veronica H., Los Angeles, CA

Hi Buddy, I think I'll take credit again this time. Thanks!
— Jeff M., Brownsville, PA

I just recently became a member of your awesome site and I would like to trade in some comics with your store for store credit so I can get some new comics.
— Chris H., Chula Vista, CA

Here's another 125 comic trade. Thanks a ton, guys! Always a pleasure!
— Keith V., Birmingham, AL

Thanks for the offer on my comics. I accept.
— Steve P., Alta, IA

Offer accepted. Thank you!
— Stephanie M., Minnetonka, MN

Your offer sounds good. I accept. Thanks again!
— Alex S., East Meadow, NY

It's okay, Buddy. I trust you entirely on that one. Thanks for the trade credit for my Atom Age Superman.
— Michael M., St. Bruno Quebec, Canada

Dear Buddy, I just wanted to thank you for being so easy to chat and work with. Thank you also for meeting me in the middle on our pricing of my collection. I hope you turn it quickly! Best of luck to you and your stores!
— Chris T., Brunswick, ME

Hey guys, Thanks for getting back to me on this. I'll definitely accept your offer. Always a pleasure doing business with you. I look forward to working with you some more in the future.
— Jon D., Westminster, CA

Hi Buddy, Thanks for the quick reply. I'll go with the trade credit for the comics I sent. Thanks so much!
— Jeff M., Brownsville, PA

Dear Buddy, Thanks for the offer for my comics. I accept. I also will be sending another box soon.
— Daniel H., Detroit, MI

Hello once again. Along with comics on your want list, I am sending and additional 57 pre-1981 comics for an offer. Thank you as always for offering this wonderful service!!!!
— Donna L., Albuquerque, NM

Thanks again for your trade option! You've given me the opportunity to try tons of other comics that I otherwise would never have read!
— Roderick B., Davenport, VA

I was very pleased with our recent sale to you. I am submitting another lot under "Option #3," so will be including additional pre-1980 comics along with the comics that were on your want list. Please treat them as a single offer lot. Thanks!
— Diane O., Alexandria, VA

I accept your offer for my comics. Thanks.
— Randall E., Two Rivers, WI

I have checked with my sister and we are happy with your offer for our comics. Can we now send more comics? As I mentioned in a previous conversation with you, we probably have 150 to 200 more. Really appreciate you help.
— Frances S., Easton, MD

Hey, Buddy! The offer looks good to me! Thanks!
— Aaron H., Jefferson, WI