Customer Feedback

You can reach us at service@mycomicshop.com

View by feedback type: All Feedback, Buyers, Sellers, Our Service, Selection

Satisfied Sellers

I just wanted to say your sell/trade interface is the best in the business. I love cataloging the collections I pick up to see what you all could use for stock!
— Aaron C., Chandler, AZ

Hello. My first time selling to you! I’ve bought a lot of comics from you over the years. Always with on-time responses from you with comics received usually within a week of purchase. Good service always. Thanks
— Robert H., Auburn, CA

Buddy, I decided about a year ago to sell the collection I had amassed since my youth. This, of course, was a decision that was made with some trepidation. Having been a record dealer for almost 40 years, I knew the ins and outs of trying to sell collections.Because of this, I contacted 3 different “reputable” dealers and told them the situation. I was looking for three different blind bids and barring some kind of absurd offers, the top bid would get the collection. Every dealer knew this from the outset. I caught the first dealer trying to put my X-Men #1 in his man-bag so that guy was escorted from the building. The second guy creeped me out more than the first. He went through all 11,000 comics twice in 45 minutes, asked me if I was impressed with how fast he was able to go through that many comics, and then asked to just buy the high-end books. When this didn’t work, he called his boss “to get me the best offer right now so we could just end negotiations”. He then came in with a low-ball offer that was never going to fly. The final person to look at the collection was Phil Harding (for your company). Phil spent about 8 hours going through everything, using your software and if he was stumped, calling your people to get clarification. He offered me various options as to how I could handle things and, as you know, we landed on cash for the bulk of the collection and consignment for 20 of the rarer books. Phil returned the following week with a cashier's check, truck and his trusty LDS sidekick, David, and were loaded up and gone in a couple of hours. I gotta say, the reason the whole thing went forward was Phil. He just came off as a sweet, honest guy who loved comics. You wouldn’t think that would matter when you’re essentially jumping off a train you’ve been on your entire life, but somehow it did. He was incredibly prescient and thorough about what was going to happen and why. I was able to know what was going on with the books at all times. So, no, as I’m sure you’re aware, not all comic dealers are the same. And comic people make as strange a bedfellow as record people, so you wouldn’t think any of the process would be considered “pleasant,” but my dealing with your company couldn’t be described as anything else. That’s it. Rant over. Feel free to use any or no part of this in a testimonial as you see fit. Thanks for everything.
— Kenneth N., , CA

I have over 100 trades with MyComicShop and I'm happy with every one. It's really changed the way I collect comics for the better.
— David A., Timonium, MD

It was a pleasure dealing with you! MyComicShop is very efficient and hassle-free; definitely a five-star experience!!! Kindly endeavor to find nice homes for the collection. It represents my fondest childhood memories!
— Samson T., Greenville, SC

Thank you for accepting my comics and giving me the best pricing available. I am very pleased with every aspect of this transaction and will definitely be using mycomicshop.com for future sales. Thanks again!
— Jeff S., Vancouver, Canada

Hello again! I've gathered together a new batch for your consideration. Thanks as always for helping me cure my comic buying habit by supplying me trade credit to work with!
— Michae T., La Center, WA

In the process of selling my comic collection, I communicated with five or six of the leading online buyers. MyComicShop not only came in at the highest offer, but they were forthright with zero BS. They responded to me quickly, sorted out the shipping process easily, and cut a check immediately after the books arrived. In my experience, they're the clear choice for anyone looking to sell a collection.
— Glenn D., Los Angeles, CA

Your website has been so helpful for cataloguing everything I have here. Between my own collection of mostly Superman-related stuff, and several long boxes given to me by others with a lot of Batman and assorted Marvel, expect to hear from me semi-regularly for a while. It's amazing to know how many of those comics given to me for free are now worth quite a bit. I'm going to be sending the best ones to CGC in small batches, and then I will get them to you.
— Chance K., Pittsburgh, PA

Thanks for providing the best buying and selling comic book shop ever!
— Sheldon F., San Marcos, CA

You all have been great. I emailed a question about one of my comics I wanted to sell. I asked the question over the weekend and received a reply first thing Monday morning. Thank you for all your help.
— Carol R., Montrose, CO

I'm a long time comic collector and buyer from you guys. I'm very excited to start selling to you. I appreciate this opportunity. You will be seeing a lot more comics coming from me. Thank you.
— Dylan O., Ventura, CA

Thanks again! You will be receiving many more comics in the future from me. Everything about your service is outstanding!
— David F., Columbia, MO

Thanks to everyone for the excellent service over the years. I have been selling, consigning, and buying from Lone Star Comics for 20+ years.
— Stephane P., Horton, Canada

It was a pleasure doing business with you! I got fast responses to my questions, the staff were polite and helpful, and the check came in a few days. You were quick to make an offer, and you increased the payment after you received the collection, even though you were under no obligation to do so. A fair and honest company! Thank you all!
— Wendy M., Foxboro, MA

Thank you so much for helping me sell my Yellow Kid and Yellow Book magazines. I’m so excited that we got that much money by selling them in your Prime Auction. I really appreciate it. Thanks!
— Peggy L., Kirkland, WA

The best place to buy, sell, and consign anywhere. There are no crazy buyer and seller premiums like other places. I plan to continue buying and selling with MyComicShop!
— David P., Waynesboro, PA

I would like to say how pleased I was with my last transaction. It was my first time selling comics to Lone Star Comics. I was very relieved that my grading was correct for the most part, and you even graded some higher. I thank you and your team for your fine service. I have lots of comics, so we will be doing lots of business together.
— Jerry E., Sailsbury, MD

It has been a pleasure to do business with you. I knew that when it came time to sell my collection, MyComicShop was the place to go. Your amazing communication, customer service, and ease of selling are appreciated.
— Gregg L., Baltimore, MD

I am a first-time customer who hasn't looked at his comic collection in a few decades, and I have just been blown away by the team at Lone Star Comics and mycomicshop.com! The website is well organized and clear, and the online want list is amazing! I put over 600 books into the system, and it was fun to go through my comics to see which ones I could consign and which I would sell outright. I had no idea about current values, and this really put my mind at ease! When I had a couple of questions, I was amazed at how genuinely considerate, patient, and clear your consignment department was! Then, when I mailed the wrong comic in one of my shipments, I received a notice right away, and then you followed up with an email and provided more specifics. This company really feels like a family-owned business, where the culture of honest business and outstanding customer service comes from the top down and everyone is on board. I am going to sell all my comics to Lone Star Comics with confidence that I am getting good advice and fair pricing! Thank you for all you do!
— Steve S., Lynchburg, Virginia

I've gotta say that was awesome, quick, and painless. I had to wait a bit for the quote and then again on delivery, but I was very pleased that the payment wasn't delayed by red tape. It was practically instant, and I INSTANTLY spent that money with you all. I had an expensive book in my sights. So not only did you get a pile of my graded books, you got an additional sale out of me. I can't wait to get the book I just ordered! You're very cool. I will be ordering more from you in the future.
— Amos L., ,

I have spent more time on your website than I'd like to admit. I love everything you do, from selling to buying comics for sale.
— Brandon B., Murfreesboro, TN

You are AWESOME! Thank you for everything! You all make me feel important. Yeah, yeah, what do I mean? Just the packing alone is enough! I have 12,000 comic books and counting. I might be contacting you all about paring down the double issues and other what not. Anyway be well and a serious THANK YOU!!
— Bob D., JUNEAU, AK

I must say how easy this process was from start to finish with mycomicshop.com. I have been in customer service for almost 20 years, and my experience with mycomicshop.com as a customer has gone well above and beyond my expectations. You provided outstanding service. If I could rate mycomicshop.com the rating would be well above 5 stars. The prompt responses from my initial inquiry to the last email I received today have made me aware of how simple, quick, and absolutely pleasurable it was to do business with you.
— Jason B., , OH

I traded in some comics and worked with one of your buyers. Everything went great and I am now using my store credit to fill out my collection. Thank you for a great shopping and selling experience!
— Ryan L., Clayton, NC

My experience with this extremely professional and well-run organization was the best. Fair, honest, and efficient. Comic buyer Alex is a consummate pro. Highest regards.
— John S., ,

I just wanted to send a personal thank you for years of excellent service. Whether it's packaging my orders with care, or checking in my sales or consignments, you always do a great job. Thank you!
— George T., ,

When I discovered Lone Star Comics, I loved the friendly service, the good prices given for my old comics, and how fast I received my checks. I will never go anywhere else. Thanks so much, Lone Star!
— Dale T., ,

Thank you for offering this comic buying service on your website. I have made multiple transactions over the last several years and have always been more than pleased with the offers that I have received. I feel that your grading is accurate, and the prices paid are very fair and often more than expected. Thanks again and I look forward to sending in my next lot of books.
— Steve L., Louisville, KY

WOW, what a fast and amazing service you guys provide. I just received my my check today. Incredible!!! The best service I have ever received from any company, and I have you to thank, Steve.
— Erol M., , Australia

This was my first time selling comics and they made the process simple and easy to understand. They also offered to buy them when others did not. I would definitely do business with mycomicshop.com again.
— Tim G., Houston, TX

Thank you for your attention to detail and high professionalism. I review the auctions weekly. I hope to trade or sell some comics in the coming months. Thanks again.
— Jon L., Oxnard, CA

Thank you so much for all the terrific books I have purchased in the past (starting in 1973) from Buddy and your fine store. Also, the many books I have sold you or placed on consignment have truly been a blessing in my life. My favorite seller by far. Best wishes for your continued success.
— John S., Travis AFB, CA

I tried out your buying service a few weeks ago, now I'm hooked.
— David A., Timonium, MD

mycomicshop.com is the absolute best online platform to buy and sell comics. Thank you!
— Matt A., Middleburg, VA

Thanks so much for having the trade option! I love having a credit and then going in and seeing what I can get to fill in spots in my collection while using your weekly sale discount too.
— Mike H., Tallahassee, FL

You are amazing. Amazing. Thank you. Thanks again for everything you do. I hope the roads have stopped being icy and that this finds you healthy and safe. You and the rest of the team are the Gold Standard in the industry and a model for how to sell a bunch of funny books and related cool stuff! Take care and have a great week.
— Mark D., Ventura, CA

Years ago, I was there for the first Lone Star Comics warehouse sale and, during the cold rain, began to love every second of that pulp smell. A big thanks to Buddy and the entire team at mycomicshop.com, as I sold several books recently and realized there is no other way to go when deciding to sell comics. Professional? Yep. Patient? Heck yes.  Will I be back? I'm already digging for the next rounds.
— Scott M., Josephine, TX

Love your store! I've made both big and small purchases from you in the past; this is my first time trying to send books the other way. Thanks for a great service!
— Gerry C., San Francisco, CA

Your company is amazing! Thank you so much!
— Nathan B., Island Lake, IL

I love it! It is super easy to sell my comics on your site!
— Stephanie C., Hopkinsville, KY

Having been in sales for 50 plus years, I feel qualified to tell you that this is AWESOME customer service. I thank you very much. Again, I am very impressed.
— Dan D., , Delaware

You make the selling and buying process easy. Thank you.
— David J., Springville, AL

I’ve been your customer since around March of this year. I really like MyComicShop.com. It’s great and I’ve had zero problems so far. In fact, one of my sub shipments came in a box that was crushed on one side, but because the books inside were packed up so nicely, nothing took any damage. I’m sending these comics in for credit, just to familiarize myself with the process. I’m sure I’ll send more soon. Thanks!
— Jake M., Fort Worth, TX

Trying to sell off my whole collection (except for a few sentimental pieces). I've worked with you before and liked the results. Looking forward to doing more business with you.
— jeff V., Saint Louis, MO

You guys are great! Getting great trades for comics I no longer read for comics I want in my collection; couldn't wish for a better deal! Jessica: We are happy to hear that you were happy with out services!
— Wy E., Cathedral City, CA

I love that you offer this a trade option service! It is a great help and a nice way to give these wonderful comics a second or third life.
— Anthony B., Perri, GA

Celebrating 100 transactions sales to you! (actually a few more than that) Thank you Buddy for everything you do for us in the comic collecting community!
— Mike Bel B., Dallas, TX

Buddy, thanks for all that you do - this whole hobby is better thanks to your efforts!
— Jordan N., Chico, CA

I'm very excited about dealing with you guys. You seem to be working on the straight. I hope you like my comics and I did this thing right. I"m a Marvel gal from way back. If Mom had kept my trunk of comics when I left for college, I'd be writing you from my houseboat in Monaco.
— Virginia R., New York City, NY