Auction in progress, bid now! Prime Auction ends Monday April 13 to Friday April 17!

Vintage Paper

Below is listed all of the titles in our Vintage Paper department, which encompasses the following categories:

  • Item #63417147
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $15,999
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4443041003
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($479.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 11, Issue 2 - February 1928. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. This issue features "The Call of Cthulhu!" By H.P. Lovecraft. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations).

    NOTE: This is the very 1st appearance in print of The Call of Cthulhu, and the very first in print mention of Lovecraft's most infamous creation - Cthulhu. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    55 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    7 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64472324
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $4,999.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4689976001
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($149.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 14, Issue 2 - August 1929. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    14 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    1 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #63988436
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4455171005
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($269.97) will be charged at checkout.
      Other items consigned by Poka

    Volume 22, Issue 4 - October 1933. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    85 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    9 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #63447426
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4455171010
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($23.97) will be charged at checkout.
      Other items consigned by Poka

    Volume 23, Issue 2 - February, 1934. THE SAPPHIRE GODDESS by Nictzin Dyalhis. Other authors include: Anthony M. Rud, Edmond Hamilton, William H. Pope, David H. Kelle, E. Hoffman Price, Alfred I. Tooke, Clark Ashton Smith, Herbert Kaufman Jr., Edith Lichty Stewart, Hazel Burden, and Hung Long Tom. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    11 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #63988459
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • All 3 edges trimmed.
    • Label #4455174015
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($10.95) will be charged at checkout.
      Other items consigned by Poka

    Volume 25, Issue 2 - February 1935. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    10 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64560521
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover

    Weird Tales (1923-1985 Popular Fiction) Pulp 1st Series Vol. 25 #4 CGC Coverless Restored

    Restored: C1

    Paper: Slightly britle

    Restoration includes: COLOR COPY FRONT COVER & BACK COVER ATTACHED WITH GLUE. COVERLESS.

    Label #4684489003

    Starts Apr 20

    Volume 25, Issue 4 - April 1935. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

  • Item #63447430
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4455171007
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($26.97) will be charged at checkout.
      Other items consigned by Poka

    Volume 26, Issue 2 - August 1935. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    14 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    1 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #63233642
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4560606003

    Volume 27, Issue 4 - April, 1936. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    15 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    5 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64131243
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Slightly britle
    • Top edge of cover & bottom edge of back cover trimmed.
    • Label #4556012005

    Volume 31, Issue 3 - March 1938. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    27 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    3 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64474593
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Restored: C1
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Restoration includes: glue on spine of cover. BOTTOM EDGE OF COVER TRIMMED.
    • Label #4679104010
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($3.15) will be charged at checkout.

    Volume 32, Issue 4 - October 1938. Edited by Farnsworth Wright. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    4 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64560567
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover

    Weird Tales (1923-1985 Popular Fiction) Pulp 1st Series Vol. 35 #7 CGC 0.5 Restored

    Restored: C5

    Paper: Cream to off white

    Slab: Chipped/broken bracket

    Restoration includes: pieces added, glue.

    Label #4684489004

    Starts Apr 20

    Volume 35, Issue 7 - January 1941. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75" x 9.75", 130 pages, B&W. Cover price $0.15.

  • Item #64474659
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4679104011
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($4.50) will be charged at checkout.

    Cover by Pete Kuhlhoff. "The Man Who Cried Wolf!" by Robert Bloch, "The Watchers" by Ray Bradbury, and "The Lost Day" by August Derleth, plus other horror and supernatural tales by Edmond Hamilton, Harold Lawlor, Thorp McClusky, Emil Petaja, Manly Wade Wellman, and Charles King. Illustrations by Hannes Bok, Boris Dolgov, Dwight Boyce, Andrew Brosnatch, Irwin J. Weill, A. R. Tilburne. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in., 96 newsprint pages, black and white (text with illustrations). Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #64560465
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover

    Weird Tales (1923-1985 Popular Fiction) Pulp 1st Series Vol. 38 #6 CGC 2.0 Restored

    Restored: C3

    Paper: Cream to off white

    Restoration includes: pieces added, glue on spine of cover.

    Label #4684489001

    Starts Apr 20

    Volume 38, Issue 6 - July 1945. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.15.